Explore all cities

New York Bagels and Delis: Where to Go and How to Order

Bagels with lox, smoked fish counters and pastrami sandwiches: the classics and how to order them.

Breakfast

Bagel with cream cheese or lox

Lunch

Pastrami on rye, matzo ball soup

Where

Lower East Side, Midtown, Upper West Side

Budget

From about $4 to $30

In short

☰ Table of contents

Bagel shop, appetizing store or deli?

Three kinds of place, three different counters. Knowing which is which saves time in the line.

Bagel shops

Bake bagels through the day and fill them to order with cream cheese, eggs or fish. Quick, cheap and best in the morning.

Appetizing stores

Sell smoked and cured fish, cream cheese and salads to eat with bagels. The fish is sliced by hand in front of you.

Delicatessens

Serve cured meats: pastrami, corned beef and brisket, piled on rye bread with mustard. Lunch rather than breakfast.

Upper West Side classics

Old family food shops with cafes attached, popular for a long weekend breakfast before Central Park or the museums.

Corner delis

Any small grocery with a grill will make an egg-and-cheese sandwich on a roll or a bagel: the everyday New York breakfast.

Where to eat a classic bagel

A New York bagel is boiled before it is baked, which gives a shiny, chewy crust and a dense crumb. Ess-a-Bagel has made large, hand-rolled bagels in Midtown East since 1976 and is known for generous fillings. In the East Village, Tompkins Square Bagels draws a weekend line for bagels with a long list of flavored cream cheeses.

The standard order is a bagel with cream cheese; the classic is cream cheese with lox, tomato, onion and capers. Plain, sesame, poppy and everything are the usual varieties. If the bagels are still warm from the oven, do not ask for yours toasted.

Smoked fish and the appetizing stores

Russ & Daughters has sold smoked salmon, herring and cream cheese from the same shop on East Houston Street since 1914. Take a number, wait to be called and ask for advice: the staff will explain the different kinds of salmon. Its sit-down cafe is nearby at 127 Orchard Street.

On the Upper West Side, Barney Greengrass has served sturgeon, nova and eggs since 1908 in a room that has barely changed, and Zabar’s at 2245 Broadway is a large food shop with a cafe next door. Both suit a slow breakfast before the Museum of Natural History.

Smoked fish is the expensive part of the order. A bagel with a little cream cheese costs a few dollars; the same bagel with hand-sliced salmon costs three or four times as much.

How much do bagels and deli sandwiches cost?

These are typical prices before tax, to help you budget. Individual shops charge more or less.

What you orderTypical priceGood to know
Bagel with butter or cream cheese$3–6The everyday order
Bagel with lox and cream cheese$14–20More at the famous shops
Egg and cheese on a roll or bagel$5–9From any corner deli
Pastrami or corned beef sandwich$25–30Large enough to share
Matzo ball soup$8–12A meal with half a sandwich
Coffee$3–5Drip coffee is cheapest

Counter orders carry sales tax of 8.875% and no tip is required. With table service at a deli, add 18 to 20 percent to the pre-tax bill.

Ordering, lines and practical tips

Bagel shops and appetizing stores are busiest on Saturday and Sunday mornings, when lines can run out of the door. Go before 9 am, after 1 pm, or on a weekday.

How to order

Choose the bagel, then the spread, then any fish or extras, and say whether it is to stay or to go. Decide before you reach the counter.

Kosher and dietary notes

Kosher-style is not the same as certified kosher: check for a certificate if it matters to you. Most bagels are vegan without the filling; gluten-free choices are limited.

Sharing

Deli sandwiches hold far more meat than one person needs. Share one between two, with soup or pickles on the side.

What to know

  • A schmear is a spread of cream cheese.
  • Lox is cured salmon; nova is cured and lightly smoked, and is what most shops serve.
  • An everything bagel is coated with seeds, onion and garlic.

Keep in mind

  • At Katz’s you are handed a ticket at the door: keep it, because you pay with it on the way out.
  • Some classic shops close early in the afternoon, so check the hours before a late visit.

Pastrami and the classic delis

Pastrami is beef cured, spiced, smoked and steamed until it is soft enough to cut by hand. It is served hot on rye bread with mustard, and with pickles on the side.

Katz’s and Russ & Daughters stand two blocks apart on East Houston Street, so one walk on the Lower East Side covers both traditions.

Guided food tastings in New York

These optional tours include tastings; check the number of stops, the neighborhood and dietary options before booking.

Greenwich Village Food Tour | Tasty Tours NYC

Greenwich Village Food Tour | Tasty Tours NYC

Join us on the ultimate food tour in Greenwich Village. This 2.5-hour tour explores one of New York City’s most vibrant neighborhoods rich with history, sightseeing, and incredible…
NYC: Greenwich Village Food Tour

NYC: Greenwich Village Food Tour

Guided walking tour of Greenwich Village with tastings of pizza, bagels and other New York classics.
Greenwich Village Food Tour

Greenwich Village Food Tour

Greenwich Village is where New York gets cool, weird, and delicious all at once. This is the neighborhood that has always done things its own way, and there’s…

Frequently asked questions about bagels and delis

What goes on a classic New York bagel?

Cream cheese and lox, often with tomato, red onion and capers, on a plain, sesame or everything bagel.

Lox is salmon cured in salt. Nova is cured more lightly and then cold-smoked; it is milder and is what most shops serve today.

For the pastrami, yes. Go mid-afternoon or late in the evening for a shorter wait, and share a sandwich.

Some are certified kosher, such as 2nd Ave Deli. Others, including Katz’s, are kosher-style and not certified.

Food experiences and visits to combine

Pair a Lower East Side food stop with the neighborhoods nearby, or breakfast on the Upper West Side with Central Park and the museums.

You might also be interested in...

The journey continues…

New York City skyline at sunset
Steeple of St. Mark's Church in-the-Bowery in the East Village
Aerial view of the buildings of Midtown Manhattan
Main concourse of Grand Central Terminal, New York
Aerial view of Central Park and Manhattan at sunset, New York
USS Intrepid aircraft carrier museum at Pier 86 on the Hudson River

Must-Do Activities & Tours

Share:
Prev
Food Halls and Markets in New York: Where to Go for an Easy Meal
Next
Best Pizza in New York: Slices, Classic Pizzerias & How to Order