Explore all cities

Best Pizza in New York: Slices, Classic Pizzerias & How to Order

From a quick slice in Greenwich Village to a coal-oven pie under the Brooklyn Bridge.

By the slice

Counter shops, eaten standing

Whole pies

Coal-oven classics with table service

Brooklyn

DUMBO, Carroll Gardens, Midwood

Budget

From about $1.50 to $5 a slice

In short

☰ Table of contents

Slice shop or whole pie?

The two kinds of pizzeria work differently. Decide which experience you want before you join a line.

Slice shops

Order at the counter, pay, and your slice is reheated in the oven for a minute. A plain slice is cheese and tomato. Two slices make a meal.

Coal-oven pizzerias

The oldest pizzerias bake whole pies in coal-fired ovens and most do not sell slices. Expect table service and a wait at peak times.

Square and Sicilian slices

Thick, rectangular slices baked in a pan. The pepperoni square has become a New York favorite in its own right.

Brooklyn pizza

Several of the city's most admired pies are across the river: under the Brooklyn Bridge in DUMBO, in Carroll Gardens and in Midwood.

Budget slices

The famous $1 slice now costs about $1.50 at the best-known chain. It is basic but filling, and still the cheapest hot meal in Manhattan.

Classic slices in Manhattan

Joe’s Pizza on Carmine Street has sold the textbook New York slice since 1975: thin, crisp at the edge and soft enough to fold. The line looks long and moves fast. A short walk east, Prince Street Pizza is known for its thick pepperoni square, topped with small cups of pepperoni that crisp in the oven. Go outside lunch and dinner hours to avoid the longest wait.

Order by the slice, say whether you want it plain or with a topping, and have your payment ready. There is little or no seating: most people eat at a standing counter or outside. No tip is expected at the counter.

Coal-oven pizzerias: whole pies only

Lombardi’s on Spring Street traces its history to 1905 and is generally described as the first pizzeria in the United States. John’s of Bleecker Street, open since 1929, bakes thin, charred pies in a coal oven in a room of carved wooden booths. Neither sells slices: you order a whole pie for the table, which feeds two.

In East Harlem, Patsy’s Pizzeria has used its coal oven since 1933 and is one of the few old-school places that also sells slices. Arrive early for dinner or expect to wait at all three.

A whole pie is the better choice for two or more people who want to sit down. Plan it for an early lunch or an early dinner, when waits are shortest.

How much does pizza cost in New York?

These are typical prices before tax, to help you budget. Individual pizzerias charge more or less.

What you orderTypical priceGood to know
Budget slice at a low-cost chainAbout $1.50Plain cheese only
Plain slice at a classic shop$3–5Toppings cost more
Square or specialty slice$5–7One is often enough
Whole pie at a coal-oven pizzeria$25–35Feeds two; toppings extra
Soda or bottled water$2–4Tap water is free at tables

Sales tax of 8.875% is added at the till. Slice shops expect no tip; at a sit-down pizzeria, add 18 to 20 percent to the pre-tax bill.

Ordering, lines and practical tips

Pizzerias are busiest from noon to 2 pm and from 6 to 9 pm, and late at night at weekends in Greenwich Village. Lines at famous shops are part of the experience, but a mid-afternoon visit is quicker.

With children

Pizza is the easiest family meal in the city. A whole pie at a table is calmer than a crowded slice counter; ask for a plain pie and add toppings on half.

Vegetarian, vegan and gluten-free

A plain or margherita slice is vegetarian. Vegan and gluten-free pies exist, but not at every old classic: check the menu before you go.

Paying

Most shops take cards, but a few classics are cash only and say so at the door. Carry a little cash for slices.

What to know

  • Fold the slice lengthwise to eat it.
  • Ask for it well done if you like a crisper crust.
  • Napkins, chili flakes, oregano and garlic powder are on the counter.

Keep in mind

  • Do not expect to sit at a slice shop.
  • Famous pizzerias rarely take reservations for small groups.
  • Pizza on Times Square is seldom the city’s best: walk a few blocks or take the subway downtown.

Pizza under the Brooklyn Bridge

The corner of Old Fulton Street in DUMBO has two of the best-known pizzerias in the city almost side by side. Combine either with a walk across the Brooklyn Bridge.

Further into Brooklyn, Lucali in Carroll Gardens and Di Fara in Midwood are destinations for pizza lovers with time: both mean a subway ride and a long wait.

Guided food tastings in New York

These optional tours include tastings; check the number of stops, the neighborhood and dietary options before booking.

Greenwich Village Food Tour | Tasty Tours NYC

Greenwich Village Food Tour | Tasty Tours NYC

Join us on the ultimate food tour in Greenwich Village. This 2.5-hour tour explores one of New York City’s most vibrant neighborhoods rich with history, sightseeing, and incredible…
NYC: Greenwich Village Food Tour

NYC: Greenwich Village Food Tour

Guided walking tour of Greenwich Village with tastings of pizza, bagels and other New York classics.
Greenwich Village Food Tour

Greenwich Village Food Tour

Greenwich Village is where New York gets cool, weird, and delicious all at once. This is the neighborhood that has always done things its own way, and there’s…

Frequently asked questions about pizza in New York

What is the most famous pizza in New York?

Joe’s Pizza for a classic slice, and Lombardi’s, John’s of Bleecker Street, Juliana’s and Grimaldi’s for whole coal-oven pies.

About $3 to $5 at a classic slice shop, and about $1.50 at the budget chains.

Slice shops do not need them. Most classic sit-down pizzerias do not take reservations for small groups, so arrive early.

Both have classics. Manhattan is more convenient for a quick slice; Brooklyn is worth it if you are already crossing the bridge to DUMBO.

Food experiences and visits to combine

Pair pizza in Greenwich Village with Washington Square Park, or a pie in DUMBO with the Brooklyn Bridge walk.

You might also be interested in...

The journey continues…

Glass towers of Hudson Yards on the West Side of Manhattan
The Met Cloisters tower rising above the trees of Fort Tryon Park
Manhattan skyline and the Brooklyn Bridge in low sun
New York City skyline seen from a rooftop
The lights of Midtown Manhattan around Times Square at night
People in Central Park in spring with the New York skyline

Must-Do Activities & Tours

Share:
Prev
New York Bagels and Delis: Where to Go and How to Order
Next
Where to Stay near Central Park: Upper West Side and Upper East Side