Explore all cities

Best Steakhouses in New York: Peter Luger, Keens & Gallaghers

Dry-aged porterhouse, mutton chops and old-school dining rooms: the classic New York steakhouses and what a dinner costs.

Brooklyn

Peter Luger in Williamsburg

Midtown

Keens and Gallaghers

Theater

Dinner before a show

Budget

A splurge: book ahead

In short

☰ Table of contents

What to order at a New York steakhouse

The menu is simple: a big cut of dry-aged beef, shared sides and a classic dessert.

Porterhouse for two

The signature cut, carved at the table and shared.

Sides to share

Creamed spinach, German fried potatoes or hash browns; one or two are enough.

Dessert

Cheesecake or a sundae, often big enough to share.

Midtown classics: Keens and Gallaghers

Keens Steakhouse on West 36th Street has a historic dining room hung with thousands of old clay pipes; order the mutton chop or a porterhouse. Lunch is served on weekdays.

Gallaghers on West 52nd Street, in the Theater District, shows its dry-aging room through the window and is a classic choice before or after a Broadway show.

Book a table at least an hour and a half before curtain time if you are going to a show.

Peter Luger in Williamsburg

Peter Luger on Broadway in Williamsburg, Brooklyn, near the Williamsburg Bridge, is the most famous steakhouse in the city. Order the steak for two or more and the thick-cut bacon as a starter. Reservations are essential for dinner.

Check payment methods before you go: the restaurant has historically had its own rules on cards.

Lunch is easier to book than dinner and some lunch dishes cost less.

How much does a steakhouse dinner cost?

Typical prices before tax and tip, to help you budget.

What you orderTypical priceGood to know
Porterhouse for two$130–180Priced per person at some places
Side dish$15–20Made to share
Glass of red wine$18–30Bottles from about $70
Dinner per person, with drinks$120–200Before tax and tip

Sales tax of 8.875% is added, and a tip of 18–22% is expected.

Booking and practical tips

Steakhouses are busiest at 7–8 pm and before Broadway curtain times.

Dress code

Smart-casual is fine at most; avoid sportswear in the evening.

Sharing

Order one large steak for two plus sides rather than individual cuts.

Lunch

Several steakhouses serve lunch on weekdays, often easier to book.

What to know

  • Steaks are usually served sliced and shared.
  • Ask how the steak is cooked: “medium rare” is the house default at many.
  • Doggy bags for leftovers are normal.

Keep in mind

  • Prices for steaks for two are often per person.
  • Popular times are booked weeks ahead.
  • Tax and tip add about 30% to the menu price.

Combine dinner with the evening

From Keens you can walk to the Empire State Building; from Gallaghers to the Broadway theaters; from Peter Luger, cross the Williamsburg Bridge or end the night at a Williamsburg rooftop bar.

See our guide to rooftop bars for a drink with a view after dinner.

Guided food tastings in New York

These optional tours include tastings; check the number of stops, the neighborhood and dietary options before you book.

Greenwich Village Food Tour | Tasty Tours NYC

Greenwich Village Food Tour | Tasty Tours NYC

Join us on the ultimate food tour in Greenwich Village. This 2.5-hour tour explores one of New York City’s most vibrant neighborhoods rich with history, sightseeing, and incredible…
NYC: Greenwich Village Food Tour

NYC: Greenwich Village Food Tour

Guided walking tour of Greenwich Village with tastings of pizza, bagels and other New York classics.
Greenwich Village Food Tour

Greenwich Village Food Tour

Greenwich Village is where New York gets cool, weird, and delicious all at once. This is the neighborhood that has always done things its own way, and there’s…

Frequently asked questions about steakhouses in New York

What is the most famous steakhouse in New York?

Peter Luger in Williamsburg, Brooklyn, followed by Manhattan classics such as Keens and Gallaghers.

Expect about $120–200 per person with drinks, before tax and tip.

Yes, for dinner, especially at weekends and before Broadway shows.

Usually smart-casual; avoid sportswear and flip-flops.

Food experiences and visits to combine

Pair dinner at Gallaghers with a Broadway show, Keens with the Empire State Building at night, or Peter Luger with a Williamsburg rooftop.

You might also be interested in...

The journey continues…

One World Trade Center rising over the Lower Manhattan skyline
The High Line elevated park in Chelsea, New York
Skylit ceiling of a modern art museum
Tree-lined street with brick houses in Greenwich Village
Walkway of the High Line park in New York
People in Central Park in spring with the New York skyline

Must-Do Activities & Tours

Share:
Prev
Best Brunch in New York: Classic Spots from SoHo to Central Park
Next
Koreatown New York: Korean BBQ & Where to Eat on 32nd Street