Explore all cities

Best Italian Restaurants in New York: West Village, Carbone & Arthur Avenue

From West Village trattorias to red-sauce classics and Arthur Avenue in the Bronx: where to eat Italian and how to get a table.

West Village

Trattorias and fresh pasta

Red-sauce classics

Meatballs, veal and big portions

Bronx

Arthur Avenue markets and delis

Budget

Book ahead or go early

In short

☰ Table of contents

Red-sauce classics or modern Italian?

New York has two Italian traditions. Decide which one you want before you book, because they suit different evenings.

Red-sauce Italian-American

Meatballs, chicken parmesan, veal and baked pasta in generous portions, born from the Italian immigrant community.

Modern trattorias

Seasonal menus, fresh pasta and Italian wines, in small and busy dining rooms.

Markets and delis

Fresh mozzarella, cured meats and sandwiches to eat on the spot or take away.

Trattorias in the West Village

The streets around Grove Street and West 10th Street hold three of the most talked-about Italian restaurants in the city. Via Carota is a rustic trattoria known for its cacio e pepe and vegetable dishes.

L’Artusi has served modern Italian food on West 10th Street for many years and is a reliable choice for pasta and wine; Don Angie on Greenwich Avenue is famous for its pinwheel lasagna for two.

Reservations go fast, especially for dinner at weekends. Try for an early table at 5 pm, a late one after 9.30 pm, or lunch where it is served.

Carbone and the red-sauce classics

Carbone on Thompson Street recreates the mid-century Italian-American restaurant, with waiters in tuxedos and a famous spicy rigatoni vodka. It is one of the hardest reservations in New York: book exactly when tables are released, or try for lunch.

Little Italy on Mulberry Street is now a few blocks of restaurants with outdoor tables. It is lively for a walk, especially during the Feast of San Gennaro in September, but read menus and prices before sitting down.

For a simpler meal, many neighborhood pizzerias and pasta bars across Manhattan serve good Italian food without the wait.

How much does an Italian dinner cost in New York?

Typical prices before tax and tip, to help you budget. The best-known restaurants charge more.

What you orderTypical priceGood to know
Pasta at a trattoria$25–40Portions vary; ask before ordering a second course
Main course$35–60Steaks and veal cost more
Glass of Italian wine$15–25Bottles start around $60
Sandwich at an Italian deli$12–20Best for lunch

Sales tax of 8.875% is added to the bill, and a tip of 18–22% is expected for table service.

Booking, timing and practical tips

The most famous Italian restaurants release tables online a few weeks ahead and fill within minutes.

Book at release time

Check the reservation app the restaurant uses and the time tables open, and set a reminder.

Eat early or late

Tables at 5 pm or after 9.30 pm are much easier to find, and some places keep seats for walk-ins.

Vegetarian and gluten-free

Most trattorias have several vegetarian pasta dishes; ask about gluten-free pasta when you book.

What to know

  • Bread, water and tap water are usually free; sparkling or bottled water is charged.
  • A shared pasta as a first course is normal in modern trattorias.
  • Many restaurants keep bar seats for walk-ins.

Keep in mind

  • Restaurants in tourist areas with menus outside are not always the best value.
  • Cancellation fees apply at many popular restaurants if you do not show up.
  • Kitchens often close earlier on Sundays.

Arthur Avenue: the Bronx Little Italy

In the Belmont neighborhood of the Bronx, Arthur Avenue is still lined with Italian bakeries, butchers, cheese shops and restaurants. The Arthur Avenue Retail Market gathers food stalls under one roof, with sandwiches and fresh pasta.

Combine it with the Bronx Zoo or the New York Botanical Garden, both a short walk or bus ride away. Go on a weekday or Saturday, because many shops close on Sunday.

Guided food tastings in New York

These optional tours include tastings; check the number of stops, the neighborhood and dietary options before you book.

Greenwich Village Food Tour | Tasty Tours NYC

Greenwich Village Food Tour | Tasty Tours NYC

Join us on the ultimate food tour in Greenwich Village. This 2.5-hour tour explores one of New York City’s most vibrant neighborhoods rich with history, sightseeing, and incredible…
NYC: Greenwich Village Food Tour

NYC: Greenwich Village Food Tour

Guided walking tour of Greenwich Village with tastings of pizza, bagels and other New York classics.
Greenwich Village Food Tour

Greenwich Village Food Tour

Greenwich Village is where New York gets cool, weird, and delicious all at once. This is the neighborhood that has always done things its own way, and there’s…

Frequently asked questions about Italian food in New York

Where is the best Italian food in New York?

The West Village has the best concentration of trattorias, including Via Carota, L’Artusi and Don Angie; Arthur Avenue in the Bronx is the most traditional Italian neighborhood.

It is pleasant for a walk and for cannoli, but choose a restaurant carefully and check prices before you sit down.

Book the moment tables are released online, try for lunch, or check for cancellations on the day.

18–22% of the bill before tax is standard for table service.

Food experiences and visits to combine

Pair dinner in the West Village with a walk around Washington Square, or Arthur Avenue with the Bronx Zoo or the Botanical Garden.

You might also be interested in...

The journey continues…

Museum of the City of New York on Fifth Avenue at 103rd Street
Red and yellow brick buildings with fire escapes, New York
Colorful cast-iron buildings on a SoHo street, New York
The Flatiron Building at Fifth Avenue and Broadway with a street clock
The Brooklyn Bridge in New York City
Aerial view of Manhattan skyscrapers with lit windows in the evening

Must-Do Activities & Tours

Share:
Prev
Where to Eat in Chinatown, New York: Dim Sum, Dumplings & Noodles
Next
Best Rooftop Bars in New York