Explore all cities

New York Bakeries & Desserts: Cheesecake, Cookies & Cronuts

Cheesecake, giant cookies, banana pudding, the Cronut and Italian pastries: the New York desserts to try and where.

Cheesecake

The New York classic

Cookies

Giant and gooey

Pastries

Cronuts and Italian classics

Budget

Most treats under $10

In short

☰ Table of contents

Which New York dessert?

Each bakery is known for one thing; pick the treat, then the place.

New York cheesecake

Dense and creamy, baked on a thin crust.

Giant cookies

Thick, crisp outside and soft inside.

Pastries

From the Cronut to cannoli and rainbow cookies.

Cheesecake and cookies

Junior’s on Broadway at 45th Street, in Times Square, serves its famous cheesecake by the slice in a classic diner open from early morning.

Levain Bakery on West 74th Street started the craze for huge, gooey cookies; there is often a short line outside.

Junior’s is open late and convenient before or after a Broadway show.

Banana pudding, Cronuts and Italian pastries

Magnolia Bakery on Bleecker Street is famous for banana pudding and cupcakes, and Dominique Ansel Bakery on Spring Street created the Cronut, with a new flavor each month.

In the East Village, Veniero’s has made Italian pastries, cannoli and cheesecake since the 19th century, with a café at the back.

Take a numbered ticket at the counter at Veniero’s, or sit in the café to order.

How much do desserts cost in New York?

Typical prices before tax, to help you budget.

What you orderTypical priceGood to know
Slice of cheesecake$9–14More with toppings
Giant cookie$5–6One is often enough for two
Banana pudding$5–9Small, medium or large
Cronut$8–10Limited daily quantity

Sales tax of 8.875% applies to most prepared food.

Lines and practical tips

Bakery lines are longest on weekend afternoons and in the evening in the West Village.

Go early

Mornings are the quietest time at most bakeries.

Take away

Most treats travel well: eat them in a nearby park.

Allergies

Ask staff about nuts and gluten; many items contain both.

What to know

  • Most bakeries are takeaway counters with little seating.
  • Cronut flavors change every month.
  • Junior’s also serves full diner meals.

Keep in mind

  • Popular items can sell out in the afternoon.
  • Lines move fast but can be long at weekends.
  • Some bakeries close early in the evening.

A sweet walk through the Village

Magnolia Bakery, Dominique Ansel and Veniero’s are all within a walk of Washington Square, so you can try two or three on the same afternoon.

A food tour of Greenwich Village is another way to taste several classics in one go.

Guided food tastings in New York

These optional tours include tastings; check the number of stops, the neighborhood and dietary options before you book.

Greenwich Village Food Tour | Tasty Tours NYC

Greenwich Village Food Tour | Tasty Tours NYC

Join us on the ultimate food tour in Greenwich Village. This 2.5-hour tour explores one of New York City’s most vibrant neighborhoods rich with history, sightseeing, and incredible…
NYC: Greenwich Village Food Tour

NYC: Greenwich Village Food Tour

Guided walking tour of Greenwich Village with tastings of pizza, bagels and other New York classics.
Greenwich Village Food Tour

Greenwich Village Food Tour

Greenwich Village is where New York gets cool, weird, and delicious all at once. This is the neighborhood that has always done things its own way, and there’s…

Frequently asked questions about New York desserts

What dessert is New York famous for?

New York cheesecake, followed by giant cookies, black-and-white cookies and the Cronut.

Junior’s in Times Square is the classic; Veniero’s in the East Village is another favorite.

The line usually moves quickly, and one cookie is enough to share.

At Dominique Ansel Bakery on Spring Street in SoHo.

Food experiences and visits to combine

Pair Junior’s with a Broadway show, Levain with Central Park, or a bakery walk with Greenwich Village and SoHo.

You might also be interested in...

The journey continues…

Passport and boarding pass held at an airport gate
The lights of Midtown Manhattan around Times Square at night
Montauk Point Lighthouse on the tip of Long Island, New York
Panorama of Midtown and Downtown Manhattan from a rooftop
The Manhattan Bridge and the Manhattan skyline
A traveler with a suitcase waiting at a transit stop

Must-Do Activities & Tours

Share:
Next
Best Brunch in New York: Classic Spots from SoHo to Central Park