Highest guest score in this selection: Warren Street Hotel
Rated 9.6 out of 10 by over 0 Booking.com guests, this 5-star hotel stands at 86 Warren Street.
Warren Street Hotel
Recommended by JustNewYork
- 86 Warren Street
- Fitness center
- Room service
Top-rated five-star hotels in New York
Four well-rated places in New York, chosen for guest scores, location and value on sampled dates.

Warren Street Hotel
Rated 9.6 out of 10 by over 0 Booking.com guests, this 5-star hotel stands at 86 Warren Street. Guests can count on a fitness center, room service and a restaurant.
Check availability
The Whitby Hotel
Rated 9.4 out of 10 by over 100 Booking.com guests, this 5-star hotel stands at 18 West 56th Street. Guests can count on a fitness center, room service and a restaurant.
Check availability
Crosby Street Hotel
Rated 9.4 out of 10 by over 0 Booking.com guests, this 5-star hotel stands at 79 Crosby Street. Guests can count on a fitness center, room service and a restaurant.
Check availability
The Peninsula New York
Rated 9.0 out of 10 by over 200 Booking.com guests, this 5-star hotel stands at 700 Fifth Avenue at 55th Street. Guests can count on a swimming pool, a fitness center and room service.
Check availabilityHow to choose where to stay in New York
Luxury hotels differ more in style and setting than in standards. Decide first what kind of stay you want.
Search New York accommodation for your dates
Choose your dates and party size to compare current availability across New York on Booking.com. For a ready-filtered luxury search, use the accommodation buttons in this guide.
Find your stay in New York
See current Booking.com rates for your dates
☰ On this page
Where the luxury hotels are
Three parts of Manhattan hold most of the five-star addresses.
Central Park South and Fifth Avenue
- Park-facing rooms and landmark buildings.
- Walk to Fifth Avenue shops and MoMA.
- The highest rates in the city.
Midtown
- Close to Broadway, Rockefeller Center and Grand Central.
- Many subway lines within a few blocks.
- Busy streets; ask about soundproofing and floor.
Downtown
- SoHo, Tribeca and the Financial District.
- Boutique scale and notable restaurants.
- Farther from Central Park and the museums.
Map of hotels in New York
Use the map to check how far each hotel is from the subway and from the places you plan to visit.
Luxury areas compared
A quick comparison of the neighborhoods where most visitors stay.
| Area | Best for | Arrival | Evenings | Walking base | Check before booking |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Central Park South | Park views and tradition | 57th Street and Fifth Avenue stations | Hotel bars and fine dining | Central Park, Fifth Avenue | Park-view supplements |
| Midtown | Theaters and shopping | Grand Central and Rockefeller Center | Lively until late | Broadway, Bryant Park | Street noise on lower floors |
| Upper East Side | Quiet elegance | Lexington Avenue line | Residential and calm | Museum Mile, Madison Avenue | Fewer restaurants open late |
| Downtown | Design and food | Canal Street, Chambers Street | Restaurants and cocktail bars | SoHo, Tribeca, the waterfront | Distance from uptown museums |
Typical hotel prices in New York
Rates below were sampled for a midweek stay in winter, the cheapest season. From spring to December, and above all in the weeks before Christmas, expect clearly higher prices.
| Tier | Price / room / night | What to expect | Best for | Hotels |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lower-priced five-star hotels | $260–350 | Five-star hotels with the lowest rates on sampled dates. | Lowest rates in January and February | See five-star hotels → |
| Five-star hotels in the middle price range | $365–465 | Five-star and top four-star hotels in the middle of the range. | Good value outside the peak weeks | See luxury hotels → |
| Top-rated five-star hotels | $1030–1340 | The highest guest scores among five-star hotels. | Book early for spring and fall | See top-rated hotels → |
| The most exclusive addresses | $485–915 | The highest rates among the hotels selected. | Rates rise sharply in December | See five-star hotels → |
Check access to your room
Five-star hotels offer accessible rooms, step-free entrances and staff assistance as standard. Mention specific needs when booking so that the right room type is assigned.
Compare the full stay
Compare the final total for the same dates and guests. Review taxes, breakfast, cleaning fees, cancellation conditions and any deposit before paying.
Five-star hotels in the middle price range in New York

Park Lane New York
A 5-star hotel at 36 Central Park South with a guest score of 7.6 on Booking.com. Facilities include a fitness center, room service and 2 restaurants.
Check availability
33 Hotel, New York City, Seaport
A 5-star hotel at 33 Peck Slip with a guest score of 8.6 on Booking.com. Facilities include a fitness center, room service and a restaurant.
Check availability
The Frederick Hotel Tribeca, a Small Luxury Hotel
A 5-star hotel at 95 West Broadway with a guest score of 8.3 on Booking.com. Facilities include a fitness center, room service and 2 restaurants.
Check availability
The Marmara Park Avenue
A 5-star hotel at 114 East 32nd Street with a guest score of 8.0 on Booking.com. Facilities include a swimming pool, a fitness center and parking.
Check availabilityLower-priced five-star hotels in New York

Sela V Hotel
One of the lower-priced options with good reviews: a 5-star hotel at 29 Ryerson Street, rated 8.4 by guests, with free Wi-Fi, a 24-hour front desk and coffee and tea in the rooms.
Check availability
The Westin New York at Times Square
One of the lower-priced options with good reviews: a 5-star hotel at 270 West 43rd Street, rated 8.1 by guests, with a fitness center, parking and wifi.
Check availability
The Evelyn NoMad
One of the lower-priced options with good reviews: a 5-star hotel at 7 East 27th Street, rated 8.4 by guests, with a fitness center, 3 restaurants and parking.
Check availability
The Benjamin Royal Sonesta New York
One of the lower-priced options with good reviews: a 5-star hotel at 125 East 50th Street, rated 8.3 by guests, with a fitness center, room service and a restaurant.
Check availabilityThe most exclusive addresses in New York

The Bowery Hotel
A 5-star address at 335 Bowery, rated 8.8 out of 10 on Booking.com. On site: a fitness center, room service and a restaurant.
Check availability
1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge
A 5-star address at 60 Furman Street, rated 8.3 out of 10 on Booking.com. On site: a swimming pool, a fitness center and a restaurant.
Check availability
Thompson Central Park New York, by Hyatt
A 5-star address at 119 West 56th Street, rated 8.2 out of 10 on Booking.com. On site: a fitness center, room service and 3 restaurants.
Check availability
Refinery Hotel - New York
A 5-star address at 63 West 38th Street, rated 8.2 out of 10 on Booking.com. On site: a fitness center, room service and 3 restaurants.
Check availabilityPros and cons of staying in New York
Strengths
- Space and comfort: larger rooms, better beds and real quiet, which are rare in New York.
- Service: concierge desks that can secure restaurant tables, theater seats and transfers.
- Location and views: many of the best outlooks over Central Park and the skyline.
Worth considering
- Price: rates are high all year and peak sharply in December and around major events.
- Extra charges: taxes, facility fees, breakfast and parking add considerably to the bill.
- Minimum stays: some hotels require two or three nights at busy times.
Frequently Asked Questions - FAQ
How much does a five-star hotel in New York cost?
On winter weekdays the lower-priced five-star hotels start at around $300 a night. The best-known addresses commonly exceed $1,000, and December is far higher.
When are luxury hotels cheapest?
January and February, midweek. Rates rise from spring and peak between Thanksgiving and New Year.
Which area has the best luxury hotels?
Central Park South and Fifth Avenue for classic grand hotels, Midtown for choice, downtown for contemporary design.
Is breakfast included?
Usually not. Check the rate details; packages with breakfast are often available at a supplement.
Do luxury hotels charge extra fees?
Many add a daily facility fee on top of taxes. It is shown in the price breakdown before you confirm.
Is a park view worth the extra cost?
If the view is the reason for your trip, yes. Otherwise a higher floor on a quieter side often gives better value.
How far ahead should I book?
For December, spring and fall weekends, several months. In winter, good rates appear much closer to the date.
Ready to book your stay in New York?
Check live rates and booking conditions on Booking.com. We may earn a commission when you book through our links, at no additional cost to you.






































